Mushroom Strain Comparison: Strain vs Strain

Use this strain vs strain tool to put two mushroom strains side by side. Most names on the list are trade names for one species, Psilocybe cubensis. Their spores fit the same published range, so a microscope will not tell two cubensis labels apart. What differs is the name, its claimed origin and the label you record. Pick two strains to see each guide’s notes. For popular pairs, read the full written comparisons below.

First strain

Second strain

Mushly sells mushroom spores for microscopy and identification only. Growing psilocybin mushrooms is illegal in many places, so check your local laws before ordering.

Popular strain vs strain pairs at a glance

Each pair below has a full written comparison. In every one, both names are Psilocybe cubensis.

PairSame species?What a slide can showFull comparison
Golden Teacher vs Penis EnvyYes, P. cubensisBoth are cubensis lines; a slide cannot confirm either pedigreeRead Golden Teacher vs Penis Envy
Jedi Mind Fuck vs Golden TeacherYes, P. cubensisSame spore range and dark purple-brown printRead Jedi Mind Fuck vs Golden Teacher
McKennaii vs Golden TeacherYes, P. cubensisSame spore range; practice in careful labelingRead McKennaii vs Golden Teacher
Blue Meanie vs Golden TeacherYes, P. cubensis (not P. cyanescens)Same spore range; record the label and binomialRead Blue Meanie vs Golden Teacher
Golden Teacher vs Inca StargazerYes, P. cubensisSame spore rangeRead Golden Teacher vs Inca Stargazer
Golden Teacher vs Purple MysticsYes, P. cubensisSame shape, size range and dark purple-brown printRead Golden Teacher vs Purple Mystics
Golden Teacher vs Matias RomeroYes, P. cubensisSame spore rangeRead Golden Teacher vs Matias Romero
Golden Teacher vs Albino A+Yes, P. cubensisCompare prints: sellers describe Albino A+ as leucisticRead Golden Teacher vs Albino A+
Lizard King vs Golden TeacherYes, P. cubensisSame shape, size range and printRead Lizard King vs Golden Teacher
Tidal Wave vs Golden TeacherYes, P. cubensisSame spore range; a slide will not tell them apartRead Tidal Wave vs Golden Teacher
Jedi Mind Fuck vs Penis EnvyYes, P. cubensisSame spore range and printRead Jedi Mind Fuck vs Penis Envy
Albino Penis Envy vs Jedi Mind FuckYes, P. cubensisPrint: APE is reported to leave a faint or pale depositRead Albino Penis Envy vs Jedi Mind Fuck
Jedi Mind Fuck vs Blue MeanieYes, P. cubensisSame spore range and printRead Jedi Mind Fuck vs Blue Meanie
Jedi Mind Fuck vs Tidal WaveYes, P. cubensisSame spore range; differences are catalogue historyRead Jedi Mind Fuck vs Tidal Wave
Jedi Mind Fuck vs B+Yes, P. cubensisSame spore range; a slide will not tell them apartRead Jedi Mind Fuck vs B+

When the strains are different species

Some names on the list are separate species, not cubensis lines. Here a slide and a spore print can help. Spore sizes often overlap, so print colour and habitat matter as much as size.

SpeciesSpore printPublished spore sizeGrows on
Psilocybe cubensis (all cubensis lines)Dark purple-brown11.5–17.3 × 8–11.5 µm (Singer and Smith, 1958)Dung
Panaeolus cyanescensJet black12–15 × 7–11 µm (general reference)Dung
Wavy Cap (Psilocybe cyanescens)Dark purple-brownAbout 10–12.5 × 7–7.5 µm (holotype data)Wood chips
Psilocybe azurescensDark purplish brown to purplish black9–13.5 × 5–8 µm (general reference)See guide

“Blue Meanie” is a nickname for Panaeolus cyanescens and also a cubensis trade name. At Mushly, Blue Meanie is the cubensis line. Always record the scientific name, not the nickname.

How to compare two strains under a microscope

Strain vs strain: side-by-side microscopy notes for two spore samples
  1. Pick two strains in the tool and open both guides.
  2. Use one format for both, a spore syringe or a spore print.
  3. Keep the method the same: mount, magnification and lighting.
  4. Write the label, the scientific name and the supplier in every entry.
  5. Record what you see. A fit to the species range does not prove a trade name.

New to slides? Start with the mushroom spores for microscopy guide and species vs strain.

Strain vs strain FAQ

Jump to question 1

What does “strain vs strain” mean for mushrooms?

It means comparing two named lines side by side. Most names are trade names for one species, Psilocybe cubensis. A few entries on the list are separate species.

Jump to question 2

Can you tell two cubensis strains apart under a microscope?

Usually not. Spores of named cubensis lines fit the published species range, 11.5–17.3 × 8–11.5 µm (Singer and Smith, 1958), with a dark purple-brown print. The label is your record of what is on the slide.

Jump to question 3

Which comparisons can a microscope or print help with?

Different species. For example, Panaeolus cyanescens has a jet-black print and P. cubensis a dark purple-brown one. Sizes overlap, so use print colour and habitat too. Some albino lines, such as Albino Penis Envy, are reported to leave a faint or pale print.

Jump to question 4

Is Blue Meanie the same as Psilocybe cyanescens?

No. At Mushly, Blue Meanie is a Psilocybe cubensis trade name. Psilocybe cyanescens is the Wavy Cap, and the nickname also refers to Panaeolus cyanescens.

Jump to question 5

Why doesn’t the tool show potency, yield or effects?

Mushly sells spores for microscopy and taxonomic research only. The tool compares names, species and spore traits, which is what a microscope can check.

Jump to question 6

Where does the comparison data come from?

From each strain’s Mushly guide. Species data comes from published descriptions. Seller origin stories are labelled as claims, not facts.

Jump to question 7

Can I share or save a comparison?

Yes. After you compare, the page address updates with both strains, so you can copy and share it.